Commentary: Shameless Political Partisanship of Media – The Fong Coverage

Dr. Lim Teck Ghee notes in his commentary how the mainstream media seem to push an agenda in the reporting of DAP’s former MP for Batu Gajah Fong Po Kuan who announced her decision not to contest in this elections.

A commentary by Dr. Lim Teck Ghee

“PO KUAN CRIES OFF”; “Fong drops a bomb” screamed the headlines of the two major papers in the country yesterday. Most readers would have wondered what earth shattering event had taken place to warrant such eye catching coverage. In fact, just glancing at the ‘bomb-drop’ headline would have led to consternation amongst readers that someone in the country was so demoralized by the way the country was run that she had decided to resort to violence or terrorism to put her message out.

Reading further beyond the headlines, the front page hot news turned out to be a decision by the Batu Gajah parliamentary representative not to contest in the coming elections. Such a pull-out of a comparable Barisan Nasional party candidate at most would have resulted in a few lines buried in the middle pages of the same papers. Interesting news but hardly warranting the sensationalistic coverage.

So, what was the angle the newspapers were targeting to the readers? The message is of the main opposition party in disarray and therefore unworthy of the trust and confidence of voters. This was a dagger aimed directly at the electorate. It also had a subtle sub-plot of creating confusion and division within the party and its supporters.

Unfortunately for the spin doctors manipulating this story, this attempt at brainwashing is not working. As the human interest aspects of the story unfold, the public will increasingly recognize the tremendous personal sacrifices that opposition party representatives – especially women – have to make when they stand up in the interests of the public and the many difficulties they encounter in serving the cause of democracy. This particular attempt at news spinning deserves to backfire badly.

In the coming days, we can expect from the mainstream newspapers, radio and television networks a steady stream of negative reporting against all the opposition parties. Exaggeration, propaganda and misinformation about the goodness, blessings and great achievements of the Barisan Nasional government alone are not regarded as sufficient to sway the public to vote against the opposition. Spinning and distortion of news about the opposition parties must be provided in equal measure – if not at a more frenzied level – to ensure a resounding Barisan Nasional victory.

How does this coverage reflect on journalistic norms and values? One of the most discerning of our journalists in a commentary piece titled “Cashing in for the elections” has written how spin doctoring becomes the flavour of the month during the election season and of the material incentives held out for journalists who participate. He wrote:

“Having covered three elections, I can vouch that if one wants to make an extra buck or even forward one’s personal agenda through political hopefuls, this is the time. The ang pows and brown envelops with wads of cash being handed out to campaign workers, voters, and yes – sadly , some journalists – are regular scenes which of course do not make it to the news pages. Those who decline these offerings have the benefit of a good night’s sleep and can write with a clear conscience.”

He ended his column by noting:

“Well, that’s the game these days. It will be a sad day indeed if voters and those who are supposedly representatives of the Fourth Estate allow instant gratification to distort their view of the bigger picture. Our future is not for barter and the sooner everyone realizes that, we will be able to look our children in the eye and tell them we made the right choices for their future.”

Our newspaper editors and colleagues at senior management level play a much bigger game and for larger personal stakes that the low and middle level journalists are accosted by individual politicians. I wonder what stories they tell their children to justify the news stories they are peddling and hope they can sleep better at night during this period or whenever they ply their trade.